I Promise You Sex and Violence

David Ireland’s taboo-buster is too determined to test the bounds of taste.

★★
theatre review (edinburgh) | Read in About 2 minutes
33329 large
121329 original
Published 04 Aug 2014
33331 large
100487 original

David Ireland’s plays tend to ride roughshod over the standards of polite society. Political correctness is his bête noire and he can’t stand softly-softly, happy-clappy liberal hypocrisy. Here, he goes gunning for our tiptoeing tolerance of race, gender and sexuality, but ties himself in knots along the way.

Ireland shows us a triangle of friends. Bunny (Keith Flemming) is bisexual, but nobody knows. His flatmate Charlie thinks he’s gay. Best mate Raymond thinks him straight. He self-defines differently with each: touchy-feely with Charlie, building-site blokey with Raymond. Bunny’s white. He’s male. He gets to do that; to keep control of his labels.

Meanwhile, Charlie identifies as a feminist, but her fondness for a good shag means she’s often dubbed a slut. Likewise Raymond, who sees himself as white according to his upbringing, but, being mixed race, is more usually deemed black.

But all this gets confused by a scattergun plot. Bunny sets his two friends up and their blundering blind date leads—inexplicably—to an equally blundering bondage and role-play session. Bunny, always pulling the strings, attempts to railroad proceedings into a three-way.

Is all this about white patriarchy? Or is it about the possibility of co-existing contradictions – slutty feminists, consensual rape and the like? Really, who can tell? Ireland’s determination to be daring—chucking dildos and faecal fetishes around willy-nilly—capsizes the play into juvenilia, and each of his characters behaves so irrationally, you want to escort them offstage and into care. Something of a shambles, to be honest.