Tom Bell Begins

Perhaps there is hope for the future – but, for now, this is tosh

comedy review (edinburgh) | Read in About 2 minutes
33332 large
39658 original
Published 21 Aug 2011
33329 large
121329 original

Does Tom Bell ever really start? Is that the point? Should we care? Thrice nay. It wouldn't be a surprise if this nervy, eccentric and eloquent 30-year-old with "a complexion of a drowned Elizabethan" (one of a handful of good lines) became the next Paul Foot.

However, given that Foot is failure and genius by turn, this is a double-edged sentiment and on this occasion Bell deserves only the former label. If ever there were a case for not unleashing a show until it is ready, this hour is it. A succession of easy targets including the lurid headlines of Love It! magazine, the naff stories carried by a local magazine he once worked on and the character of a misogynistic Australian comedian are joined with a guest appearance by Neptune, who asks us to re-think sea-based proverbs in the face of unsustainable fishing, and Bell's butler Alfred, a Michael Caine tribute character.

Even out of context you get the idea of how much this show is groping for some comedy manna. It should, at least, be hit-and-miss but the results resemble a bad day on Family Fortunes. The premise on which all this foppish frippery is hung is equally loose, following, chronologically, a few key autobiographical points, but initially presented as a Hollywood style "re-boot" of his life. Despite this mess, Bell's CV shows prolific activity and he's not the sort to disappear without trace. Perhaps there is hope for the future then – but, for now, this is tosh.