Russell Kane: Smokescreens and Castles

★★★★★
archive review (edinburgh) | Read in About 2 minutes
33328 large
102793 original
Published 22 Aug 2010
33332 large
121329 original

Russell Kane was good last year. Clever, and not afraid to show it, he ran intellectual rings around many of his contemporaries, who lacked his store of half-remembered sociological and literary sources. But too often it felt a little artificial – disaffectedly intellectual for no sake other than its own. This year, Kane has ditched some of the act. He doesn’t seem driven to overegg his extraordinary perceptiveness with irrelevant bookishness; he’s learned that he can do subtlety as well as virtuoso verbosity.

In Smokescreens and Castles, Kane examines—and it is a thorough examination, rather than a series of observations—the way in which we build 'castles' of various sorts to hide or protect what we really feel. His by-now-familiar mine is his own family. But Kane digs not just for comedy, but astute and sensitive conclusions about a group of people he clearly cares deeply about – even his hard-man, diesel-guzzling, racist father. Taking his audience on a metaphorical tour around his ex-council house family castle—one of only three on his street to have taken up Thatcher’s right-to-buy—he grapples with the huge social upheaval of the ’80s and makes it touchingly personal.

Kane is an accomplished performer and a master of energising an audience. But what marks him out is a capacity for subtlety; an eye for authentic characterisation; an ear for kitchen sink drama. There are few comedians who can whip an audience into 59 minutes of laughter, before closing on a minute of whispered poignancy. This year, Kane isn’t good. He’s brilliant.